{
  "format": "driftproof-answers/2",
  "receipt_hash": "32028d8d47628e683aebec2f14ebe378154d595e983a50e11c08962ce41184f8",
  "model_id": "claude-opus-5-5",
  "answers": {
    "e348cc93bd62fad61d3aba7879e612905cd0ee2e86fa0f87f59de7a2075aecea": "```html\n<div\n  data-composition-id=\"data-chart\"\n  data-composition-src=\"compositions/data-chart.html\"\n  data-start=\"2\"\n  data-duration=\"15\"\n  data-track-index=\"1\"\n  data-width=\"1920\"\n  data-height=\"1080\"\n></div>\n```\n\n- `data-composition-id` must match the block's internal ID (`data-chart`).\n- `data-composition-src` assumes the default block install path (`compositions/<name>.html`). If you've changed `paths.blocks` in `hyperframes.json`, use that path instead.\n- `data-track-index` only sets the Studio timeline row. Use CSS `z-index` to control layering.\n- With these values the block plays from host time 2s to 17s.",
    "6ba5fcbb8dc01658f36eee800ee87ac4bb08f1ecbcc885be2e20c60d221e575a": "```html\n<div\n  data-composition-id=\"data-chart\"\n  data-composition-src=\"compositions/data-chart.html\"\n  data-start=\"2\"\n  data-duration=\"15\"\n  data-track-index=\"1\"\n  data-width=\"1920\"\n  data-height=\"1080\"\n></div>\n```\n\nThe block will play from host time 2s to 17s.\n\nNotes:\n- `data-composition-id` must match the block's internal ID (`data-chart`), or it won't wire up.\n- `data-composition-src` assumes the default install path for blocks (`compositions/`). If `hyperframes.json` sets a different `paths.blocks`, update the path to match.\n- `data-track-index=\"1\"` only sets which row the block appears on in the Studio timeline. It does not control layering. Use CSS `z-index` to put the block above or below other elements.",
    "11deb2f5f43f97f2504018250b8464a730e4d062ea916b49e2ff6a9d7ebfbe36": "```html\n<div\n  data-composition-id=\"data-chart\"\n  data-composition-src=\"compositions/data-chart.html\"\n  data-start=\"2\"\n  data-duration=\"15\"\n  data-track-index=\"1\"\n  data-width=\"1920\"\n  data-height=\"1080\"\n></div>\n```\n\nPlace it inside your host composition's root `<div data-composition-id=\"...\">` in `index.html`. Notes:\n\n- `data-composition-id` must match the block's internal ID (`data-chart`).\n- `data-composition-src` assumes the default install path (`compositions/<name>.html`). Adjust it if `paths.blocks` in `hyperframes.json` points somewhere else.\n- The block plays from host time 2s to 17s.\n- `data-track-index=\"1\"` only sets the Studio timeline row. Use CSS `z-index` to control which layer is on top.",
    "bc016bacb9e828ea86f1b24f8ac8fd6b97022249a0a545812d8620c9f1057162": "Here's the host element, assuming the block's markup lives in `compositions/data-chart.html` (no path was given, so adjust `data-composition-src` to the real location):\n\n```html\n<div\n  id=\"data-chart-host\"\n  data-composition-id=\"data-chart\"\n  data-composition-src=\"compositions/data-chart.html\"\n  data-start=\"2\"\n  data-duration=\"15\"\n  data-track-index=\"1\"\n  data-width=\"1920\"\n  data-height=\"1080\"\n></div>\n```\n\n- **`data-composition-id=\"data-chart\"`** matches the block's internal composition id.\n- **`data-start=\"2\"`** places it at 2 seconds on the host timeline.\n- **`data-duration=\"15\"`** matches the block's 15-second duration, so it ends at host time 17.\n- **`data-width` / `data-height`** mirror the block's 1920×1080 size. These are declared inside the block itself, so they're optional here, but they make the size explicit.\n- **`data-track-index=\"1\"`** is a placeholder layer. Pick a free track index that doesn't overlap other clips in the 2–17s window.",
    "aaf3834309886a1e2485f663c4e8beb887ac281f25ab9fb130eb1fd175fafd80": "```html\n<div\n  data-composition-id=\"data-chart\"\n  data-composition-src=\"compositions/data-chart.html\"\n  data-start=\"2\"\n  data-duration=\"15\"\n  data-width=\"1920\"\n  data-height=\"1080\"\n></div>\n```\n\n- **`data-composition-id`** must match the internal composition id, `data-chart`.\n- **`data-start=\"2\"`** places the block at host time 2s, so it runs until 17s on the host timeline.\n- **`data-duration`, `data-width` and `data-height`** mirror the block's declared 15s and 1920×1080.\n- **`data-composition-src`** was not in the facts you gave. The path shown is a placeholder, so point it at wherever the data-chart block file actually lives.",
    "d97ba7cbfd7a25964b3859adfd421957e080e68cda5ebba6df3952bf386ed32b": "```html\n<div\n  data-composition-id=\"data-chart\"\n  data-composition-src=\"compositions/data-chart.html\"\n  data-start=\"2\"\n  data-duration=\"15\"\n  data-track-index=\"1\"\n  data-width=\"1920\"\n  data-height=\"1080\"\n></div>\n```\n\n- `data-composition-id=\"data-chart\"` matches the internal composition id.\n- `data-start=\"2\"` places it at host time 2s, so it plays until 17s.\n- `data-duration=\"15\"`, `data-width=\"1920\"`, `data-height=\"1080\"` match the declared composition.\n- `data-composition-src` and `data-track-index` are assumptions. You didn't give a file path or track. Change `compositions/data-chart.html` to the block's real location, and set the track index so it doesn't conflict with other clips on the host timeline.",
    "af402ba82c73ab619ddbcb620e74507af76d90c5e067b110b7586238c276b140": "```html\n<div\n  data-composition-id=\"data-chart\"\n  data-composition-src=\"compositions/data-chart.html\"\n  data-start=\"2\"\n  data-duration=\"15\"\n  data-width=\"1920\"\n  data-height=\"1080\"\n  data-track-index=\"1\"\n></div>\n```\n\n- `data-composition-id=\"data-chart\"` matches the internal composition's id.\n- `data-start=\"2\"` places the block at host time 2s, so it runs until 17s.\n- `data-duration=\"15\"`, `data-width=\"1920\"` and `data-height=\"1080\"` repeat the composition's declared values.\n\nTwo values were not in your facts, so I made them up:\n\n- **`data-composition-src`**: replace the path with the actual location of the data-chart file.\n- **`data-track-index=\"1\"`**: set this to whatever layer slot the block should use in your host timeline.",
    "03b6abf7acf1b121bd1a90b4e0643cb8badec9e7034f91ce4bcc8e9627783418": "Here's the host element, placed in the parent composition:\n\n```html\n<div\n  data-composition-id=\"data-chart\"\n  data-composition-src=\"compositions/data-chart.html\"\n  data-start=\"2\"\n  data-duration=\"15\"\n  data-width=\"1920\"\n  data-height=\"1080\"\n></div>\n```\n\n- **`data-composition-id=\"data-chart\"`** must match the id declared inside the data-chart block.\n- **`data-start=\"2\"`** starts it at 2 s on the host timeline, so it plays from 2 s to 17 s.\n- **`data-duration=\"15\"`**, **`data-width=\"1920\"`**, and **`data-height=\"1080\"`** repeat the block's declared length and size.\n- **`data-composition-src`** is an assumed path, since you didn't give the file location. Change it to wherever the data-chart block actually lives. If the block is defined inline in the same document, remove this attribute.",
    "478912e6e162a0cceda1b6c78e114c7044d59f47814fdc8d3551f23211b93aa2": "```html\n<div\n  data-composition-id=\"data-chart\"\n  data-composition-src=\"compositions/data-chart.html\"\n  data-start=\"2\"\n  data-duration=\"15\"\n  data-width=\"1920\"\n  data-height=\"1080\"\n></div>\n```\n\n- `data-composition-id=\"data-chart\"` matches the block's internal composition id.\n- `data-start=\"2\"` places the block at 2 seconds on the host timeline.\n- `data-duration=\"15\"`, `data-width=\"1920\"` and `data-height=\"1080\"` repeat the declared duration and size.\n- `data-composition-src` was not in the facts you gave me. `compositions/data-chart.html` is a placeholder, so replace it with the real path to the block's file.",
    "734533e80b13bcf051f5fa42a398ce637502a4ef936cd635085a995bb9593d3b": "A component and a block are installed with the same command but integrated differently. A **block** is a self-contained composition that you *reference*. A **component** like `grain-overlay` is a snippet that you *merge* into a composition you already have.\n\n## Integrating the grain overlay (component)\n\nAfter `hyperframes add grain-overlay`, the file lands at `compositions/components/grain-overlay.html`, unless `paths.components` in `hyperframes.json` points elsewhere. That file is not loaded by anything on its own. You copy its parts into your host composition, usually `index.html`:\n\n1. **Read the installed file** and find its three sections: markup, `<style>`, and any `<script>`.\n2. **Markup:** paste the overlay's HTML elements inside your composition's root `<div data-composition-id=\"...\">`. For a grain layer this is usually near the end, so it sits above the content.\n3. **Styles:** copy the `<style>` rules into your composition's existing style block. Use CSS `z-index` to keep the grain on top of your content. `data-track-index` only affects the Studio display and does not control layering.\n4. **Script:** if the snippet has JS, paste it into your composition's script before your timeline code, so anything it defines exists when the timeline runs.\n5. **Timeline hooks:** if the snippet's comment block describes GSAP integration, such as fading the grain in or animating its intensity, add those calls to your own timeline.\n\nThe grain then runs on the host's timeline. A component has no width, height or duration of its own. It inherits the canvas and timing of whatever composition you paste it into.\n\n## How a block differs\n\nA block such as `data-chart` installs to `compositions/data-chart.html` and stays a separate file with its own dimensions, duration and timeline. You don't copy its contents. You mount it from the host with a placeholder element:\n\n```html\n<div\n  data-composition-id=\"data-chart\"\n  data-composition-src=\"compositions/data-chart.html\"\n  data-start=\"2\"\n  data-duration=\"15\"\n  data-track-index=\"1\"\n  data-width=\"1920\"\n  data-height=\"1080\"\n></div>\n```\n\n- `data-composition-id` must match the block's internal ID.\n- `data-start` and `data-duration` place it on the host timeline.\n- `data-width` and `data-height` set its canvas.\n\nThe CLI prints a starter snippet, but you add the ID, start and track attributes yourself.\n\n## Side by side\n\n| | Component (grain-overlay) | Block (e.g. data-chart) |\n|---|---|---|\n| Default install path | `compositions/components/<name>.html` | `compositions/<name>.html` |\n| Own dimensions / duration | No, inherits the host's | Yes |\n| How it's used | Paste HTML, CSS and JS into the host | Reference via `data-composition-src` |\n| Timing | Driven by your host timeline | Positioned with `data-start` / `data-duration` |\n| Updating later | Re-merge by hand, since your copy is now part of the host | Replace the file; the host reference stays the same |\n\nIn short, a grain overlay is an effect layered over your existing scene, so it becomes part of that scene. A block is a scene of its own that you drop onto the timeline.",
    "393e42b6fc99e464a006f5d7792757554712c7430c58f0e34f00815bd636066e": "## Integrating the grain overlay (a component)\n\nA component has no dimensions, duration or timeline of its own. It isn't referenced as a separate file at render time. You copy its parts into your host composition.\n\nAfter `hyperframes add grain-overlay`, the snippet lands at `compositions/components/grain-overlay.html`. That is the default, and `paths.components` in `hyperframes.json` can change it. To wire it in:\n\n1. **Read the installed file.** It is a source to copy from, not something you link to.\n2. **HTML:** paste its elements inside your composition's root `<div data-composition-id=\"...\">`, next to your existing content.\n3. **CSS:** merge its `<style>` block into your composition's styles. Layering is controlled by CSS `z-index`. An overlay like grain normally sits above the content and usually ignores pointer events.\n4. **JS (if any):** paste its `<script>` content into your composition's script, *before* your timeline code, so anything it defines exists when the timeline is built.\n5. **Timeline hooks:** if the snippet's comment block describes GSAP integration, add those calls to your existing timeline. That makes the grain animate in step with everything else, for example fading in at a set point or flickering for a stretch.\n\nThe grain becomes part of the host composition. It shares the host's canvas, its clock, and any CSS it inherits.\n\n## How a block differs\n\nA block such as `data-chart` is a standalone sub-composition with its own dimensions, duration and timeline. It installs to `compositions/<name>.html`, and you **reference** it rather than paste it:\n\n```html\n<div\n  data-composition-id=\"data-chart\"\n  data-composition-src=\"compositions/data-chart.html\"\n  data-start=\"2\"\n  data-duration=\"15\"\n  data-track-index=\"1\"\n  data-width=\"1920\"\n  data-height=\"1080\"\n></div>\n```\n\n- `data-composition-id` must match the block's internal ID.\n- `data-start` and `data-duration` place it on the host timeline.\n- `data-width` and `data-height` set its canvas size.\n- `data-track-index` only sets which Studio timeline row it appears on. Use CSS `z-index` for actual stacking.\n\n## Side by side\n\n| | Component (grain-overlay) | Block (data-chart) |\n|---|---|---|\n| Default install path | `compositions/components/` | `compositions/` |\n| Own size, duration, timeline | No | Yes |\n| How it's used | Copy HTML, CSS and JS into the host | Reference via `data-composition-src` |\n| Timing | Driven by your host timeline (GSAP hooks) | `data-start` / `data-duration` |\n| Isolation | Merged into the host's scope | Self-contained sub-composition |\n| Editing later | Edit your composition directly | Edit the block file |\n\nThe printed snippet from `hyperframes add` is only a starting point in both cases. For a component, the work is merging the pieces into the host's markup, styles and script. For a block, the work is filling in the wiring attributes, especially the matching `data-composition-id`, `data-start` and `data-track-index`.",
    "78049df21db43a7e83cc6c0c5c3c93c24ba6f65ad192571b98a37322635e8b5e": "Here's how a component like `grain-overlay` gets integrated, and how that differs from wiring a block.\n\n## Integrating the grain-overlay component\n\nA component is an effect snippet. It has no dimensions, duration or timeline of its own, so you merge it into the host composition by hand. After `hyperframes add grain-overlay`, the file lives at `compositions/components/grain-overlay.html` by default. That path is configurable via `paths.components` in `hyperframes.json`.\n\n1. **Read the installed file.** It contains HTML elements, a `<style>` block, and possibly a `<script>`.\n2. **Copy the HTML** into your composition's root `<div data-composition-id=\"...\">`. Place it where it should sit in the stacking order. For an overlay that is usually last, or above the content.\n3. **Copy the `<style>` block** into your composition's existing styles. Control layering with CSS `z-index` so the grain sits on top of the content.\n4. **Copy any `<script>` content** into your composition's script, placed *before* your timeline code so anything it defines exists when the timeline runs.\n5. **Wire up the GSAP timeline, if needed.** If the snippet's comment block describes timeline integration calls, add those calls to your existing timeline.\n\nOnce merged, the grain is part of the host. It shares the host's canvas size, duration and timeline, and there is no separate file reference at render time.\n\n## Compared with a standalone block\n\n| | Component (e.g. grain-overlay) | Block (e.g. data-chart) |\n|---|---|---|\n| Nature | Effect snippet | Standalone sub-composition |\n| Own dimensions/duration/timeline | No, it inherits from the host | Yes |\n| Default install path | `compositions/components/<name>.html` | `compositions/<name>.html` |\n| How it's integrated | Copy and paste its HTML, CSS and JS into the host | Referenced from the host via a placeholder element |\n| Timing control | Through your own timeline code | Through `data-start` / `data-duration` attributes |\n\nA block is not pasted in. You reference it with a single element:\n\n```html\n<div\n  data-composition-id=\"data-chart\"\n  data-composition-src=\"compositions/data-chart.html\"\n  data-start=\"2\"\n  data-duration=\"15\"\n  data-track-index=\"1\"\n  data-width=\"1920\"\n  data-height=\"1080\"\n></div>\n```\n\n- `data-composition-id` must match the block's internal composition ID.\n- `data-start` and `data-duration` place it on the host timeline.\n- `data-width` and `data-height` give its canvas size.\n- `data-track-index` only sets the Studio timeline row. Visual layering is still done with CSS `z-index`.\n\nThe CLI's printed snippet is only a starting point for blocks. You'll typically need to add the ID, start and track attributes yourself.\n\n## In short\n\n- **Component:** merge its markup, styles and script into your composition and drive it from your own timeline.\n- **Block:** leave it as a separate file and mount it with `data-composition-src` plus timing and size attributes.",
    "b77d6efb8a89a62f561d927089e4072206b7de7733813bf3b7e2e29854281448": "# Integrating a Grain Overlay Snippet vs. a Standalone Block\n\nThis is based on general registry conventions, not your project's files, so check exact file names and paths against what was installed. I'm assuming a registry where **components** are snippets you merge into a composition and **blocks** are self-contained sub-compositions, as in HyperFrames-style tooling.\n\n## The core difference\n\n| | Component snippet (your grain overlay) | Standalone block |\n|---|---|---|\n| **What you get** | Markup, styles and maybe a small script to paste into a host | A complete composition with its own root, size and duration |\n| **Where it lives** | Inside the host composition's file | Its own file, referenced from the host |\n| **Timeline** | Shares the host's timeline and clock | Has its own internal timeline, placed as one clip |\n| **Styling scope** | Lives in the host's CSS cascade | Isolated inside its own composition |\n| **Dimensions** | Inherits the host canvas | Declares its own width and height, scaled into the slot |\n\n## Integrating the snippet into an existing composition\n\n1. **Paste the markup inside the composition root.** Put the grain element as a direct child of the root container, usually last, so it sits above the content:\n   ```html\n   <div id=\"root\" data-composition-id=\"main\" data-width=\"1920\" data-height=\"1080\">\n     <!-- existing scenes/clips -->\n     <div class=\"grain-overlay\"></div>\n   </div>\n   ```\n\n2. **Merge the styles into the host stylesheet.** The overlay should:\n   - cover the full frame (`position: absolute; inset: 0;`)\n   - sit on top (a high `z-index`)\n   - never block interaction (`pointer-events: none;`)\n   - blend rather than cover (`mix-blend-mode: overlay` or `soft-light`, with low `opacity`)\n\n   Watch for class-name collisions with your existing CSS, since nothing isolates the snippet.\n\n3. **Wire up timing, if it animates.**\n   - If the grain uses a CSS keyframe or noise shift, make sure the renderer captures it deterministically. Many frame-by-frame renderers only respect animations driven by the composition's timeline.\n   - If the snippet includes a script, register its animation on the host timeline rather than creating a separate one.\n   - To show grain for only part of the video, give it the host's start and duration attributes like any other clip.\n\n4. **Bring in any assets.** If the grain uses a noise texture (PNG or SVG), copy it into your assets folder and fix the path. An inline SVG `feTurbulence` filter has no external asset.\n\n5. **Check the stacking order.** Anything you add later that should sit above the grain, such as crisp captions, needs a higher `z-index` or must come after the overlay.\n\n## Using a standalone block instead\n\nA block isn't merged. You reference it from the host as a sub-composition, roughly like this:\n```html\n<div data-composition-src=\"compositions/grain.html\"\n     data-start=\"0\" data-duration=\"10\" data-track-index=\"5\"></div>\n```\n- It brings its own root, dimensions, styles and timeline, so there's no CSS bleed and no timeline merging.\n- You control it from outside only through placement attributes (start, duration, track or layer).\n- Blending with the content underneath depends on how the renderer composites sub-compositions. Blend modes may not cross the composition boundary the way they do inside a single document.\n\n## Which to use\n\nFor a grain overlay, the **snippet approach is usually better**. Grain is a thin, full-frame, blend-dependent layer that should share the host's canvas, timing and stacking context. A block makes more sense for self-contained pieces such as a title card, lower third or intro sequence, which have their own internal animation and benefit from isolation.\n\nIf you share the snippet's actual contents or your composition's root markup, I can say exactly where each piece goes.",
    "5d00e4f4757c314e957f5e2c78d36b025549e8eed928675724c702a82c9976c3": "# Integrating a Grain Overlay Component Snippet\n\nI'm assuming the usual split in composition-based video and motion tooling. A **component** is a snippet you merge into a composition you already have. A **block** is a self-contained composition that you place as a unit. If your tool's docs describe a component differently, follow the docs.\n\n## Integrating the component snippet into an existing composition\n\nOnce installed, the snippet becomes part of your composition's own source. The steps are:\n\n1. **Paste the markup into the composition.** Place the grain element last, or give it the highest stacking order, so it sits above every other layer.\n\n2. **Make it cover the full frame.** It should fill the composition's width and height. That usually means absolute positioning with a zero inset.\n\n3. **Keep it non-interfering.**\n   - Set `pointer-events: none` so it never captures interaction.\n   - Use a blend mode such as `overlay` or `soft-light`, plus a low opacity, so it textures the content instead of covering it.\n\n4. **Merge its styles and any animation.**\n   - Move the snippet's CSS into the composition's style scope.\n   - If the grain animates (for example, a jittering noise offset), attach that animation to the composition's existing timeline. It should not run on its own clock.\n\n5. **Set its timing within the composition.**\n   - By default it should span the full duration.\n   - If you only want grain on certain scenes, give it the same start and duration attributes your other layers use.\n\n6. **Check for collisions.** The snippet now shares a namespace with your content, so rename any IDs or class names that clash with yours.\n\nThe result is a single composition with one timeline and one render. The grain lives inline, so you can tune its opacity, blend mode or timing next to everything else.\n\n## How that differs from a standalone block\n\n| | Component snippet | Standalone block |\n|---|---|---|\n| **Where it lives** | Copied into your composition's source | Its own composition file, with its own size, duration and timeline |\n| **How you use it** | Edit it in place, merged with your layers | Reference or embed it as a unit, as a sub-composition or clip with a start time and track |\n| **Timeline** | Shares the host composition's timeline | Runs its own internal timeline; the host only positions it |\n| **Styling scope** | Shared with the host, so watch for clashes | Isolated, so clashes are unlikely |\n| **Effect on your content** | Can blend directly with the layers beneath it | Can only affect what's underneath if it's layered above that content in the host |\n| **Reuse and updates** | Each composition has its own copy, so changes don't propagate | One source file, so editing it updates every composition that uses it |\n\n## When to use which\n\n**Use the component** when the grain is a finishing touch on one composition. It fits best when you want it to blend tightly with that composition's layers and share its timing.\n\n**Use a block** when you want a reusable, isolated unit. That suits a full scene, or a branded intro and outro, that you drop into many compositions and maintain in one place.\n\nFor a grain overlay specifically, the component form is usually the better fit. Grain only works if it sits on top of and blends with your existing content, and inline integration makes that straightforward.",
    "fd8d5dd9a36bca106b300346caa1b10697b388dd855f56ff799a13e4df49b93b": "The core difference: **a block is something you reference, while a component snippet is something you merge into your own composition.** I can't check your project, so file names and attribute names below are typical and may differ from your setup.\n\n## Standalone block (for comparison)\n\n- A block is a **self-contained composition** with its own root element, dimensions, timing, styles and scripts.\n- You mount it from a parent composition by reference, such as a nested composition element pointing at the block's file. You can give it a start time, duration and track or layer.\n- It runs in its own scope. Your composition doesn't need to know how it works internally.\n- It suits finished pieces like a title card, lower third or transition scene that occupy a time range.\n\n## Component snippet (the grain overlay)\n\nA snippet has no root or timeline of its own. It's a fragment of markup, CSS and sometimes a script that you merge into the composition you want to affect.\n\n1. **Open the installed snippet file**, usually under a `components/` directory. It typically contains:\n   - an overlay element, such as a `<div class=\"grain-overlay\">` or a `<canvas>`\n   - a `<style>` section with positioning, the noise texture or SVG `feTurbulence` filter, `mix-blend-mode`, and opacity\n   - possibly a small script that animates or re-seeds the noise each frame\n\n2. **Paste the markup into your composition's root**, as the last child so it stacks above your content. Make sure it:\n   - uses `position: absolute; inset: 0;` (or fixed) to cover the full frame\n   - has a high `z-index`\n   - has `pointer-events: none` so it doesn't affect layout or interaction\n\n3. **Merge the CSS** into the composition's existing stylesheet. Check for clashes in class names, IDs and SVG filter IDs (`#grain`, `#noise`, and so on).\n\n4. **Merge the script, if any**, into the composition's existing timeline or animation setup rather than starting a separate loop.\n   - If your composition uses a central timeline (for example GSAP) or a frame callback, hook the grain animation into it.\n   - This keeps grain deterministic during rendering. A free-running `requestAnimationFrame` or `Math.random()` loop can flicker or differ between renders, so use a frame-based or seeded noise offset.\n\n5. **Set timing.** By default the overlay is present for the whole composition. To limit it to a section, add the timing attributes or timeline tweens your composition uses to fade its opacity in and out.\n\n6. **Tune it** with opacity (usually about 0.05–0.2), blend mode (`overlay`, `soft-light` or `multiply`) and grain scale or frequency.\n\n## Quick comparison\n\n| | Block | Component snippet |\n|---|---|---|\n| How it's used | Referenced or mounted as a nested composition | Copied or merged into your composition |\n| Own timeline or root | Yes | No, uses the host's |\n| Scope | Isolated | Shares the host's DOM, CSS and scripts |\n| Typical role | A scene or segment in time | A layer or effect over existing content |\n| Integration work | Point to it and set start and duration | Paste markup, merge styles and scripts, check for conflicts |\n\n**Rule of thumb:** for grain over everything you already have, merge the snippet into the top-level composition so it covers all nested content. Only wrap it as its own block if you want to reuse it as a separately timed layer across many compositions.",
    "eb3ed122d26155e94c240980207142ed172872732e35660a17aa11f993b40a61": "# Integrating a grain overlay component snippet vs. a standalone block\n\nI'm assuming a HyperFrames-style registry, where **blocks** are self-contained sub-compositions and **components** are snippets you merge into a composition you already have. I can't inspect your files, so the paths and attribute names below are the conventional ones. Check them against the installed snippet.\n\n## Component snippet (what you have)\n\nA component is not a composition. It has no timeline or duration of its own and isn't mounted automatically. You merge its parts into the host composition:\n\n1. **Markup.** Copy the overlay element (usually a full-frame `<div>` or `<canvas>` with a grain/noise class) into the host composition's root container. Place it last, or give it a high `z-index`, so it sits above all other layers.\n2. **Styles.** Move the snippet's CSS into the host's `<style>`. Keep or confirm:\n   - `position: absolute; inset: 0;` (full-frame coverage)\n   - `pointer-events: none;`\n   - `mix-blend-mode` (e.g. `overlay` or `soft-light`) and `opacity`, which control intensity\n   - the SVG `feTurbulence` filter or noise texture it references. If it's an inline `<svg><filter>`, copy that too, or the `url(#id)` reference breaks.\n3. **Animation.** If the grain flickers by shifting its offset, add those tweens to the **host's existing timeline**, not a new one. Make them span the host's full duration, or use a repeat that covers it. Seek-driven rendering needs every motion to be deterministic from the timeline. Avoid `requestAnimationFrame` or `Math.random()` per frame unless the snippet seeds them deterministically.\n4. **Scoping.** The snippet now shares the host's CSS and ID namespace. Rename classes or IDs if they collide.\n5. **Verify.** Preview or lint the composition. Scrub to several timestamps and confirm the grain is visible, on top, and doesn't shift the content's colours more than intended.\n\n## Standalone block (for comparison)\n\nA block is its own composition file with its own root, styles, and timeline. You don't paste its internals. You reference it from the host with a clip element, e.g.:\n\n```html\n<div data-composition-src=\"compositions/grain-overlay.html\"\n     data-start=\"0\" data-duration=\"10\" data-track-index=\"99\"></div>\n```\n\n- Its timing comes from `data-start`/`data-duration` on the host element.\n- Its layering comes from the track index or `z-index`.\n- Its styles and timeline are isolated, so there are no naming collisions.\n- Updating it means editing one file, and every host that includes it picks up the change.\n\n## Key differences\n\n| | Component snippet | Standalone block |\n|---|---|---|\n| How it's added | Copy-merge into host HTML/CSS/JS | Referenced via `data-composition-src` |\n| Timeline | Host's timeline | Its own, offset by `data-start` |\n| Duration | Must be matched to host manually | Set by `data-duration` on the clip |\n| Scope | Shared; watch for collisions | Isolated |\n| Customisation | Edit inline per composition | Edit once; affects all users |\n| Best for | Effects tightly coupled to one scene | Reusable, independent segments |\n\nFor a grain overlay that should cover the whole piece, the snippet approach is fine. Put it last in the root, give it full-frame absolute positioning and `pointer-events: none`, and tie any flicker to the host timeline. If you want the same grain across many compositions without re-pasting, wrapping it as a block is the cleaner option.",
    "d50b94f84dfef5ef8966ed12bfa7cb347ab03a78f674844d58472abbc7b3d216": "I don't have your project's files or the snippet's contents, so this is a general explanation. Exact attribute names and file paths will depend on your framework.\n\n## Component snippet vs. standalone block\n\n| | **Component snippet** | **Standalone block** |\n|---|---|---|\n| What it is | A fragment of markup, CSS and possibly JS that you merge into a composition you already have | A self-contained composition with its own root, dimensions, duration and timeline |\n| How it's used | Pasted or merged into your composition's markup | Referenced as a clip or sub-composition and placed on a track |\n| Timeline | Shares the host composition's timeline | Has its own internal timeline, offset by where you place it |\n| Styling | Shares the host's CSS scope, so name collisions are possible | Isolated scope |\n| Blending | Blends directly with the layers beneath it | Usually renders in its own stacking context |\n\n## Integrating the grain snippet into an existing composition\n\n1. **Place it at the top of the stack.** Add the overlay element as the last child of your composition's root, or give it the highest z-index or track. That way it sits above all footage and graphics.\n\n2. **Make it cover the whole frame and stay non-interactive.**\n   ```css\n   .grain-overlay {\n     position: absolute;\n     inset: 0;\n     pointer-events: none;\n     mix-blend-mode: overlay; /* or soft-light / multiply */\n     opacity: 0.15;           /* tune to taste */\n   }\n   ```\n\n3. **Make it span the full duration.** Either give it no timing attributes, so it persists, or set its start to `0` and its duration to the composition's full length. If you change the composition's length later, update this as well.\n\n4. **Merge the CSS and JS carefully.**\n   - Move the snippet's styles into your composition's stylesheet.\n   - Rename any classes, IDs or keyframes that clash with yours.\n   - Load any assets it uses, such as a noise texture or SVG `feTurbulence` filter, from a path your composition can resolve.\n\n5. **Drive any animation from the host timeline.** If the grain flickers through JS, such as shifting the background position or changing the turbulence seed, attach that animation to the composition's existing timeline. Don't let it run on its own `requestAnimationFrame` or timer. This keeps scrubbing, seeking and frame-by-frame rendering consistent.\n\n6. **Keep it deterministic.** Avoid unseeded `Math.random()` per frame. Derive the noise offset or seed from the current frame or time so every render produces the same output.\n\n## Why the distinction matters for grain specifically\n\nThe main practical difference is **blending**. A snippet inside your composition can use `mix-blend-mode` against the actual footage underneath. A standalone block often renders into an isolated layer. Its blend mode then only affects content inside the block, so the grain may look like a flat grey haze instead of texture.\n\nIf you used it as a block, you'd need to apply the blend mode to the block's container in the parent composition, if your framework allows that. As a snippet, it just works.\n\nThe trade-off is reusability:\n- **A block** is easier to drop into many compositions unchanged.\n- **A snippet** needs per-composition integration, meaning steps 3–5, each time you use it.\n\nIf you paste the snippet's contents or tell me which framework you're using, I can map these steps onto the exact attributes and files.",
    "c37acab2df3b457d797b70bd19070a7d1c45704695b476a90d9971f0dba91b49": "I can't see the snippet's files, so this is based on how component snippets and standalone blocks typically differ in composition registries. Check the installed snippet's comments for exact class names and parameters.\n\n## The core difference\n\n| | Standalone block | Component snippet (your grain overlay) |\n|---|---|---|\n| **What it is** | A self-contained composition with its own file, dimensions, duration and timeline | A fragment of markup, styles and maybe a small script, meant to live inside another composition |\n| **How it's used** | Mounted or referenced from a parent, like a clip on a track | Pasted or merged into the host composition's own source |\n| **Timeline** | Owns its timeline; the parent places it at a start time and duration | Shares the host's timeline and clock |\n| **Sizing** | Declares its own canvas size | Inherits the host's canvas and fills it |\n| **Isolation** | Styles and scripts are scoped to the block | Lives in the host's scope, so names can collide |\n\n## Integrating the grain overlay into an existing composition\n\n1. **Place the markup last (topmost) in the root of the composition.** Grain should sit above all content, so put it as the final child of the composition root, not inside a scene or clip wrapper. Otherwise it only covers that scene.\n\n2. **Make it cover the frame and ignore input.** The overlay element should be absolutely positioned at `inset: 0`, have a high `z-index`, and use `pointer-events: none`. The snippet probably already includes this. Just make sure the host root is a positioning context (`position: relative`).\n\n3. **Merge the styles into the host.**\n   - Copy the snippet's CSS into the composition's stylesheet.\n   - Check for class or keyframe name collisions with existing styles. Prefix them if needed (for example, `.grain-overlay`).\n   - Keep the blend mode (`mix-blend-mode: overlay` or `soft-light`) and opacity as provided, then tune them to your footage.\n\n4. **Tie it to the host timeline.** A standalone block has its own clock. A snippet doesn't, so:\n   - Static or CSS-animated grain: make sure the animation is driven by the composition's time, not wall-clock time, so renders are deterministic. Use whatever the framework uses to seek CSS animations.\n   - Script-driven grain (canvas noise, seed changes per frame): register its update with the host's timeline or frame callback instead of `requestAnimationFrame` or `setInterval`. Otherwise the noise won't match frame-by-frame in rendered output.\n   - Duration: the overlay should span the full composition length unless you only want it on certain sections. In that case, give it a start and end on the host timeline.\n\n5. **Pass parameters as host-level values.** Any intensity, size or speed settings are now variables in your composition, such as CSS custom properties on the root or the host's props or variables. They are not inputs to a separate block.\n\n6. **Assets.** If the grain uses a noise texture image, copy it to the host's asset folder and fix the relative path in the CSS.\n\n## When to use a standalone block instead\n\nUse a block if you want the grain as a reusable layer you can drop onto many compositions without editing each one. Also use one if you want it isolated from the host's styles and scripts, or if you want to toggle it as a separate track. Use the snippet when you want the grain baked into one composition, controlled by that composition's variables, and rendered as part of the same layer stack. That's the usual case for a finishing texture.\n\n**Quick check after integrating:** render a few frames. The grain should cover the full frame edge to edge, appear above every scene, not block anything interactive in preview, and look identical when you re-render the same frame.",
    "d707fe941e07b87de24f1ee7bbb60cd7121c1ef473b9b8c548b82432640b8631": "# Discovery and installation order for a shimmer sweep\n\n## 1. Search the catalog before building anything\n\n\"Shimmer sweep\" is a named visual, so check the registry first. Discovery needs no project, no account and no installs. The search runs locally and sends nothing.\n\n```bash\nnpx hyperframes catalog --query \"shimmer sweep light glint across text or a surface\"\n```\n\n- **Query by intent, in English.** Describe what the effect does rather than guessing an item name. The default tier ranks on words shared with each item's name, title and description, so a wording mismatch can hide a match.\n- **`--on-device` ranks by meaning instead.** It requires a one-time 33 MB model download that you must consent to.\n- **Use `--json` in agent or CI runs.** It tells you which tier answered, so you can confirm a ranking actually happened. A non-zero `dropped` means the search index and the registry are out of sync.\n- **Browsing is the slower fallback.** Use `npx hyperframes catalog --type component` only if the search gives nothing useful.\n\n## 2. Pick a result and note its type\n\nThe CLI's own examples include `shimmer-sweep`, so a direct hit is likely. Confirm it in the results anyway, and check whether it is a component or a block. The type decides where it installs and how you wire it.\n\n## 3. If nothing fits, report the gap before hand-authoring\n\n```bash\nnpx hyperframes feedback --search-miss \"<query you ran>\" --wanted \"<the move you needed>\" --tier <tier>\n```\n\n`catalog --query` prints this command pre-filled. Report on either tier, and describe the effect rather than an imagined item name. This is the only step that sends your query anywhere.\n\n## 4. Have a project before installing\n\nDiscovery works anywhere, but `add` writes files into a project. Its paths come from `hyperframes.json` and default to `compositions/` and `compositions/components/`. Without a project, create one first (for example with `hyperframes init <dir>`), or point `add` at it with `--dir`.\n\n## 5. Install, with network access\n\n```bash\nnpx hyperframes add shimmer-sweep --dir .\n```\n\n- **Name resolution:** the name is matched as an exact item first. Only if no item matches is it treated as a tag, which would install every block with that tag.\n- **Dependencies:** any registry dependencies are installed before the item itself.\n- **Network:** `add` always needs it. Only manifests are cached, so offline you can search but not install.\n- **Headless runs:** add `--no-clipboard` in CI or other headless environments.\n\n## 6. Wire it into `index.html`\n\n**If it is a component** (installed to `compositions/components/shimmer-sweep.html`), merge the snippet by hand:\n- Paste its HTML into your composition's `data-composition-id` div.\n- Paste its `<style>` into your styles.\n- Paste any script before your timeline code.\n- Add any GSAP timeline calls described in the snippet's comment block.\n\n**If it is a block** (installed to `compositions/shimmer-sweep.html`), include it with `data-composition-src`, and set:\n- a matching `data-composition-id`\n- `data-start` and `data-duration`\n- `data-width` and `data-height`\n- `data-track-index`, which only sets the Studio display row; use CSS `z-index` for layering.\n\n**In short:** search, then choose, then report a gap if needed, then create the project, then `add`, then wire it in.",
    "bf05587dc262f1024b15a2650049e1d9d43c1e65c3d96cb81c63579165eff8e4": "# Shimmer sweep: discovery first, then install\n\n## 1. Search the catalog first\n\nA shimmer sweep is a named visual. Check the registry before hand-building anything. Search doesn't need a project, an account, or any installs. It ranks all roughly 400 hosted items locally and sends nothing anywhere.\n\n```bash\nnpx hyperframes catalog --query \"a light shimmer that sweeps across text or a surface\"\n```\n\n- **Describe the move in English**, even if the video is in another language. Non-English queries return `No searchable words in query`.\n- **Check which tier answered.** The default `words` tier only matches shared vocabulary in names, titles, and descriptions. `--on-device` ranks by meaning but needs a one-time model download you must opt into. With `--json`, the envelope names the tier.\n- **Expect a component.** The quick reference already shows `shimmer-sweep` as an install target, so a component of that name likely exists. Confirm it in the results rather than assuming.\n- **Ignore unservable items.** Anything this registry can't serve is dropped after ranking and counted in `dropped`.\n\nIf nothing fits, report the gap before hand-authoring:\n\n```bash\nnpx hyperframes feedback --search-miss \"<query>\" --wanted \"<the move you needed>\" --tier <tier>\n```\n\nThis is the only step that sends a query anywhere.\n\n## 2. Have a project to install into\n\nSearch works without a project, but `add` writes files into one. Install paths come from `hyperframes.json` (components default to `compositions/components/`). So set up or choose the project before installing.\n\n## 3. Install\n\n```bash\nnpx hyperframes add shimmer-sweep --dir <project>\n```\n\n- The name resolves as an exact item first. Only if nothing matches is it treated as a tag.\n- Registry dependencies install before the requested item.\n- **This step needs the network.** Cached manifests keep discovery working offline, but item files are fetched on every install.\n- In CI or headless runs, add `--json` and `--no-clipboard`.\n\n## 4. Wire it into the composition\n\nAs a component, shimmer-sweep has no dimensions or timeline of its own, so there's no `data-composition-src`. Instead:\n\n1. Read `compositions/components/shimmer-sweep.html`.\n2. Paste its HTML elements into your composition's `<div data-composition-id=\"...\">`.\n3. Merge its `<style>` into your styles.\n4. Put any `<script>` content before your timeline code.\n5. If its comment block describes GSAP hooks, add those calls to your timeline.\n\n**Order:** search (no project needed) → report a gap if nothing fits → set up the project → `add` (network required, dependencies first) → paste the snippet into the host composition.",
    "2d534944f17f39ec21b08935f10679bd95d128da483902114215057785ff69ad": "# Shimmer sweep: discovery first, then install\n\n## 1. Search before building anything\n\nA brief that names a visual treatment, like \"shimmer sweep\", is the cue to check the registry before writing any CSS or GSAP. You don't need a project, an account, or any installed items for this. Search ranks the whole hosted catalog (about 400 items) locally and sends nothing over the network.\n\n```bash\nnpx hyperframes catalog --query \"a glossy light shimmer sweeping across text or a surface\"\n```\n\nThings to keep in mind:\n\n- **Describe the move, in English.** Describe what the effect does rather than guessing an item name. The catalog is indexed in English, so a query in another language returns `No searchable words in query`.\n- **The default tier matches words.** It only ranks items whose name, title or description shares your vocabulary. `--on-device` ranks by meaning instead, but it needs a one-time, consented 33 MB model download.\n- **Check what actually answered.** With `--json`, the envelope reports which tier ranked the results.\n- **`dropped` means a version mismatch.** A non-zero `dropped` count means the search index knows items this registry can't serve, so the two are from different generations.\n- **Confirm the item's type in the results.** A `shimmer-sweep` name appears in the CLI's own examples, but whether it is a block or a component decides how you wire it.\n\n## 2. If nothing fits, report the gap first\n\nIf no result does the job, on either tier, file a report before hand-authoring the effect:\n\n```bash\nnpx hyperframes feedback --search-miss \"<query you ran>\" --wanted \"<the effect you needed>\" --tier <tier that answered>\n```\n\n`catalog --query` prints this line pre-filled, and `--json` includes it as `report_gap`. This is the only discovery step that sends anything externally. Describe the effect you wanted, not an item name you imagined.\n\n## 3. Install\n\nInstallation comes after discovery and has its own requirements:\n\n1. **A project to install into.** `add` writes files into a project, using the paths configured in `hyperframes.json`. You don't have a project yet, so create one first (`hyperframes init <dir>`). Then run `add` inside it or point at it with `--dir`.\n2. **Network access.** Only manifests are cached. The item's files are fetched on every `add`, so offline you can search but not install.\n3. **Then run add:**\n   ```bash\n   npx hyperframes add shimmer-sweep --dir <project>\n   ```\n   - The name is resolved as an exact item name first. Only if no item matches is it treated as a tag, which installs every block with that tag.\n   - Registry dependencies are installed automatically before the requested item.\n   - In headless or agent runs, use `--json` and `--no-clipboard`.\n\n## 4. Wire it in\n\n- **If it's a component** (installed to `compositions/components/shimmer-sweep.html`):\n  1. Paste its HTML into your composition's `data-composition-id` div.\n  2. Paste its `<style>` into your styles.\n  3. Put its `<script>` before your timeline code.\n  4. Add any GSAP timeline calls described in its comment block.\n- **If it's a block** (installed to `compositions/shimmer-sweep.html`), reference it from `index.html` with:\n  - `data-composition-src`\n  - a `data-composition-id` matching the block's internal ID\n  - `data-start`, `data-duration`, `data-width` and `data-height`\n  - `data-track-index`, which only sets the Studio row (use CSS `z-index` for layering)\n\n## Order in short\n\n1. Search in English.\n2. Pick an item, or report the gap if nothing fits.\n3. Init a project.\n4. `add` while online.\n5. Wire it according to its type.",
    "22bd0c2f5bba8362dd4396b29179cb9280964936aca4ec7ac1165517fa493599": "# Discovery and installation order for a shimmer sweep\n\nThe brief doesn't name a tool, platform, or stack, so the main risk is installing or signing up for things too early. Work through it in this order:\n\n## 1. Clarify the brief (no installs, no account)\n- **Target medium:** web UI (a loading skeleton or highlighted text), mobile, video/motion graphics, or a design file?\n- **Constraints:** an existing framework, brand timing and easing, reduced-motion requirements.\n- **Required tool:** does the brief demand a specific product, or just the effect?\n\n## 2. Discover options (read-only, no account needed)\n- **Web first:** a shimmer sweep usually needs no dependency. It's an animated `linear-gradient` with a `background-position` or `transform: translateX` keyframe, plus a `prefers-reduced-motion` fallback. Rule this option in or out first.\n- **Then:** if a framework or component library is required, look at its docs or registry for an existing shimmer or skeleton component.\n- **Only if needed:** if a hosted service is involved (an animation asset platform, a design tool plugin), check its public docs to confirm what actually needs an account.\n\nThe goal is to pick one approach before creating anything.\n\n## 3. Set up the project\n- The working directory is already a git repo, but it has no commits and no branch checked out yet. Make an initial commit, or create `main`, before adding anything, so later changes have a clean baseline.\n- Then scaffold only what the chosen approach needs. For plain CSS, that's a single HTML/CSS file.\n\n## 4. Create an account (only if step 2 showed it's required)\n- An account is outward-facing and hard to undo, so confirm with whoever owns the brief before signing up.\n- Use the identity they specify. Don't assume a personal email is the right one.\n\n## 5. Install dependencies (only if required)\n- Install the minimum: one package, pinned, added after the project exists so it lands in the manifest and lockfile.\n- Skip this step entirely for the CSS approach.\n\n## 6. Implement and verify\n- Build the sweep: gradient band, animation duration, easing, loop or one-shot.\n- Check it in the target environment, including the reduced-motion behaviour.\n- Commit.\n\n## Why this order\n- Discovery comes before the project and account so you don't create things you won't use.\n- The project comes before installs so dependencies are recorded properly.\n- The account comes last and only on demonstrated need, because it's the least reversible step.\n\nFor a typical web shimmer, steps 4 and 5 drop out completely.",
    "5c8163265a92fb2c4dfea60e29d33bc48890882eee4e440b0496ab70a00c04d4": "# Shimmer Sweep: Discovery and Installation Order\n\nA \"shimmer sweep\" is a highlight gradient that moves across an element. It's usually a skeleton loader or a \"shine\" pass over text or a logo. Since you have no project and no account yet, the order matters mostly so you don't sign up for or install things you don't need.\n\n## 1. Pin down the brief (before any discovery)\n\nAnswer these first, because they decide everything downstream:\n- **Target medium:** web UI, native mobile, or a rendered or motion asset (video, Lottie, design mockup)?\n- **Purpose:** loading placeholder, or a decorative shine?\n- **Constraints:** brand colors, timing and easing, looping, and whether to respect reduced-motion settings.\n\n## 2. Discovery: pick the approach that matches the medium\n\n| Medium | Typical approach | Account needed? |\n|---|---|---|\n| Web (plain) | CSS `linear-gradient` + `@keyframes` on `background-position` or a transformed pseudo-element | No |\n| Web (React/Vue etc.) | A skeleton/shimmer component library from the package registry, or hand-rolled CSS | No (installing from public registries is anonymous) |\n| Flutter / Android / iOS | Community shimmer packages, or a custom gradient animation | No |\n| Lottie / motion asset | Author in a motion tool, export JSON | Often yes (hosted tool or asset platform) |\n| Design mockup | Design tool prototype or plugin | Yes (design tool account) |\n\nDuring discovery, check maintenance activity, license, bundle size, and accessibility support. I can't verify current package names or versions from here, so confirm those yourself at install time.\n\n**Recommendation:** for web UI, start with plain CSS. It needs no dependency and no account, and it's usually a few lines.\n\n## 3. Installation ordering\n\n1. **Account, only if the chosen tool requires one.** Skip this for CSS or public packages. Create it before the project only when the project itself lives in that service, as with design or Lottie tools.\n2. **Create the project.** Initialize it so there's a manifest and lockfile (or the equivalent) to record dependencies.\n3. **Install the dependency, if any, into that project.** Doing this after the project exists means the dependency is pinned in the manifest and lockfile rather than installed globally or ad hoc.\n4. **Implement the sweep.** Set gradient width, angle, duration (roughly 1–2 s is common), and loop behavior.\n5. **Verify:**\n   - Animate `transform` or `background-position` rather than layout properties, for performance.\n   - Honor `prefers-reduced-motion` or the platform equivalent.\n   - Check contrast against both light and dark themes.\n   - Confirm the effect stops once content loads.\n\n## Short version\n\nClarify the medium, then choose the approach. Create an account only if that tool demands one. Create the project next, then install into it, then build and test.",
    "1d3ea5ac747c81f95e5fb7f2f4b1068d5387c109a95daa7175a0752e7210af7f": "# Discovery and installation ordering for a shimmer sweep\n\nA \"shimmer sweep\" usually means a highlight band that moves across a placeholder or text, as in skeleton loaders or \"loading…\" labels. Since you have no project and no account yet, the order matters: **discover first, commit last**. Each step should only happen once the step before it has narrowed the choice.\n\n## 1. Pin down the brief (no setup needed)\nAnswer these before looking at tools:\n- **Target platform:** web (React, Vue, plain CSS), mobile (React Native, Flutter, SwiftUI), or a design tool (Figma, Lottie, After Effects).\n- **Where it's used:** a skeleton loader, a text shimmer, or a one-off hero effect.\n- **Constraints:** bundle size, `prefers-reduced-motion` support, theming, and licensing.\n\nThis decides whether you need a dependency at all. On the web, a shimmer sweep is often just a CSS animated `linear-gradient` with `background-position` keyframes, with no package or account involved.\n\n## 2. Discover options (still no account)\nBrowse anonymously:\n- **Public registries:** npm, pub.dev, CocoaPods, or a component registry like shadcn-style collections. Compare maintenance activity, downloads, license, and peer dependencies.\n- **Docs and demos:** check whether the effect matches the brief, including direction, speed, and gradient width.\n- **Design marketplaces** (e.g., LottieFiles), if the brief is for an asset rather than code. Browsing is usually free; downloading may need a login.\n\nWrite down a shortlist and the exact install command or asset source for each option.\n\n## 3. Decide whether an account is actually required\n- Most code libraries need **no account**. Package managers install public packages anonymously.\n- Accounts are typically needed only for paid or premium components, design-asset downloads, or hosted services. Create one **only if** your chosen option requires it, and only after you've chosen.\n\n## 4. Create the project\nScaffold the project (framework CLI, `git init`, and so on) **before** installing anything. Installing first leaves dependencies with no manifest to record them in. Make an initial commit so the dependency addition shows up as its own clean change.\n\n## 5. Install, then implement\n1. Install the chosen package, or add the CSS keyframes or asset.\n2. Lock the version (lockfile committed).\n3. Build the shimmer component, add a reduced-motion fallback, and verify it against the brief.\n\n## Recommendation\nFor a typical web brief, skip the dependency. Implement the sweep with a CSS gradient animation inside your newly scaffolded project. Use a library or marketplace account only if the brief calls for something CSS can't easily do, such as a complex Lottie animation or a native-mobile shimmer.\n\n*Note:* As instructed, I didn't run any tools, so I haven't checked any specific package's current status. The ordering above is general guidance.",
    "6f36cb2219af862267b5f39975b09f9f7b0591390fa6aae87b3597c56f4a98d2": "# Shimmer sweep: discovery and installation order\n\nA shimmer sweep is a skeleton-loading effect: grey placeholder shapes with a lighter gradient band moving across them. Do discovery before installing anything. You can do almost all of it without a project or an account.\n\n## 1. Clarify the brief\n\nPin down the following, because each one changes what you'd look for:\n- **Platform:** web (React, Vue, plain HTML), Flutter, native iOS/Android, or a design or motion mockup.\n- **Scope:** a single loading state or a reusable component.\n- **Constraints:** brand colours, dark mode, sweep direction and speed, and support for reduced motion.\n\n## 2. Discovery (no project or account needed)\n\nCheck the options in this order and stop when one fits:\n1. **Native or no-dependency approach.** On the web, a shimmer is about 15 lines of CSS: a `linear-gradient` background, an animated `background-position` in `@keyframes`, and a `prefers-reduced-motion` fallback. This is often the best answer because it adds no dependency.\n2. **The design system or UI kit the brief already implies.** Many kits ship a Skeleton component. Some only pulse rather than sweep, so check that.\n3. **Dedicated packages.** Examples are `react-loading-skeleton` (web), `shimmer` on pub.dev (Flutter), and Facebook's Shimmer (iOS/Android). Browsing and comparing these on public registries needs no login.\n4. **Evaluate candidates** on:\n   - maintenance activity\n   - licence\n   - bundle size\n   - accessibility (ARIA busy states, reduced motion)\n   - theming support\n\nThe output of this step is one decision: hand-rolled, or a specific package and version.\n\n## 3. Create the project\n\nYou can only install a package once a project exists, because the install needs a manifest to record it in:\n1. Install the toolchain (for example Node.js with npm/pnpm, or the Flutter SDK).\n2. Scaffold the project. This creates `package.json`, `pubspec.yaml`, or the equivalent.\n3. Initialise version control so the dependency change is tracked.\n\n## 4. Account (usually optional)\n\n- Installing **public** packages from npm or pub.dev needs no account.\n- You need an account only to **publish** packages, use a **private or paid registry**, or use a hosted service such as a design-asset platform or deployment host.\n- If you do need one, create it and authenticate the CLI before installing anything that depends on it.\n\n## 5. Install and implement\n\n1. Add the chosen package, or write the CSS or widget yourself.\n2. Commit the lockfile.\n3. Build the skeleton shapes to match the real content layout.\n4. Wire the shimmer to the actual loading state.\n5. Respect reduced-motion preferences.\n\n## 6. Verify\n\nCheck these before calling it done:\n- It works in light and dark themes.\n- The sweep timing feels right (roughly 1–1.5 seconds per pass).\n- It doesn't cause layout shift when real content replaces it.\n- It's announced sensibly to screen readers.\n\n## Recommendation\n\nSince you're starting from nothing, prototype the pure-CSS or native version first. Reach for a package only if the brief needs many reusable skeleton variants. That keeps the project free of dependencies and accounts until you actually have a reason for them.",
    "61e224bf5ad83f374d7aba5756e6eb28766f3f0f50614d6b0347a3973aadbdbe": "# Discovery before installation: getting a shimmer sweep from zero\n\nA \"shimmer sweep\" is a highlight gradient that moves across an element, usually a skeleton placeholder, a button, or text. You have no project and no account, so the order of steps matters. Discovery needs neither. Installation needs a project, and sometimes an account.\n\n## 1. Discovery (no project, no account)\n\nDecide **what** you need before you commit to **where** it lives:\n\n- **Clarify the brief.** Pin down the target (skeleton loader, CTA button, or text), the direction and speed, whether it loops, and whether it should respect `prefers-reduced-motion`.\n- **Survey the options.** These are listed roughly from lightest to heaviest:\n  1. **Pure CSS:** a `linear-gradient` background animated with `@keyframes` on `background-position`, or a pseudo-element with `translateX`. This needs no dependency or install.\n  2. **A copy-in component registry** (for example, shadcn-style \"add\" CLIs). You browse publicly, and the CLI copies the source into your repo.\n  3. **An npm package or animation library**, installed as a dependency.\n  4. **A hosted or design-tool asset** (for example, Lottie or a paid UI kit). These sometimes require login to download.\n- **Check gating.** Note which options need an account, such as a private registry, a paid tier, or token-based access. Public docs and demos usually don't.\n\nThe output of discovery is a chosen approach plus its prerequisites, such as the framework, styling system, and auth needs.\n\n## 2. Installation ordering\n\nEach step depends on the one before it:\n\n1. **Create the project.** Installers and registry CLIs need something to install into, such as `package.json`, framework config, and Tailwind or CSS setup. Running a component CLI before this either fails or scaffolds defaults you didn't choose.\n2. **Set up the styling foundation.** Install Tailwind, CSS variables, or a theme config if your chosen component assumes it. Shimmer components often rely on custom keyframes added to config.\n3. **Create the account and authenticate, only if required.** Do this after the project exists, because tokens often go in project-scoped files like `.npmrc`, `.env`, or a registry config. Skip this step entirely for CSS or public-registry options.\n4. **Install peer dependencies** such as an animation library or utility helpers.\n5. **Add the shimmer component or asset.**\n6. **Verify.** Check the visuals, the reduced-motion fallback, and performance. Prefer animating `transform` or `background-position` over layout properties.\n\n## Recommendation\n\nStart with the pure-CSS approach unless the brief demands something more. It removes steps 3 to 5 entirely, needs no account, and still satisfies most shimmer briefs. Escalate to a registry or library only if discovery shows a concrete need, such as matching an existing design system.",
    "8d69a0fb00a72e3359fa5f9185b30b4cd55d49df7736410edef126015585c25c": "# Shimmer sweep: discovery and installation order\n\nA shimmer sweep is the light band that slides across a placeholder while content loads. You often don't need to install anything for it. That changes the order: **discover and decide first, then create the project, then create an account only if your chosen source requires one, then install.**\n\n## 1. Clarify the brief (no project or account needed)\n- **Target:** web (CSS/React/Vue), native, or a motion asset like Lottie?\n- **Scope:** skeleton placeholders, text, or a decorative highlight on a button or card?\n- **Constraints:** brand colors, sweep direction and speed, dark mode, and `prefers-reduced-motion` support.\n\n## 2. Discover options (no project or account needed)\nYou can browse docs, component registries, package pages and example galleries anonymously. Typical candidates:\n- **Plain CSS:** an animated `linear-gradient`. No dependency.\n- **Your UI kit's skeleton component**, if you'll already use a kit.\n- **A small skeleton or shimmer package** from npm.\n- **A motion asset marketplace** (Lottie or similar). Downloading often needs an account.\n\nRule out options here, before anything touches a project.\n\n## 3. Decide\nIf a CSS-only shimmer fits, stop looking for packages. It's about this much code:\n\n```css\n.shimmer {\n  background: linear-gradient(90deg, #eee 25%, #f5f5f5 50%, #eee 75%);\n  background-size: 200% 100%;\n  animation: sweep 1.4s linear infinite;\n}\n@keyframes sweep { to { background-position: -200% 0; } }\n@media (prefers-reduced-motion: reduce) { .shimmer { animation: none; } }\n```\n\n## 4. Create the project\nDo this before installing anything. A package needs a manifest (`package.json` or equivalent) and a lockfile to land in. Running an install with no project creates a stray manifest in the wrong place or fails outright.\n\n## 5. Create an account only if needed\nDo this only if the chosen source gates downloads or licensing, such as a paid asset or marketplace file. Account creation is outward-facing and hard to undo, so do it once you know you need it.\n\n## 6. Install or add\n- Add the package with the project's package manager, or paste the CSS or component in.\n- For downloaded assets, commit the file and record its license or source.\n\n## 7. Verify\nCheck the shimmer in light and dark themes and with reduced motion enabled. Also confirm the animation stops when the content loads.\n\n**Why this order:** each step is a prerequisite for the next. You can't install without a project. You shouldn't create an account until you've chosen a source that requires one. And for a basic shimmer, the likely outcome is no install and no account at all.",
    "3a8ee165adb394f6001e8ca82c78ad33865acc5a7de789c6eea7b9bdfb6e90df": "# Shimmer sweep: discovery and installation order\n\nA \"shimmer sweep\" is a highlight band that moves across an element. It's usually a loading-skeleton placeholder, or sometimes a decorative sheen on text or a logo. You have no project or account yet, so the main rule is: **don't install or sign up for anything until you know you need it.** Many shimmer effects need no dependencies.\n\n## 1. Discovery: clarify the target first\n\nThe brief alone doesn't say where the effect will run. Find out:\n\n- **Platform:** web (CSS/JS), React Native, Flutter, iOS/Android native, a motion file (Lottie/After Effects), or a design mockup (Figma).\n- **Purpose:** a loading skeleton, or a one-off decorative sweep.\n- **Constraints:** the existing stack, any design system, and reduced-motion and accessibility requirements.\n\nYour answers decide whether you need a library, a plugin, an account, or nothing at all.\n\n## 2. Pick the lightest option that works\n\nPrefer options in this order:\n\n1. **Built-in or no dependency.** On the web, a CSS `linear-gradient` background animated with `@keyframes` on `background-position` does the job. Flutter and SwiftUI can do it with a gradient mask and an animation controller. Nothing to install.\n2. **Your stack's existing component.** Many UI kits already include a Skeleton component with shimmer, such as MUI, Chakra, or shadcn-style kits.\n3. **A small, well-maintained package.** Examples: a `shimmer` package for Flutter, or a skeleton or shimmer library for React Native. Check its maintenance activity, license, bundle size, and peer-dependency compatibility before choosing.\n4. **A tool that requires an account.** Examples: Lottie or LottieFiles assets, Figma plugins, or a hosted animation service. Only go this route if the brief needs authored motion assets.\n\n## 3. Installation order\n\nOnce you've chosen, do the steps in this order. Each step depends on the one before it.\n\n1. **Create an account, only if step 2 landed on option 4.** Do it before anything else, because asset downloads, API keys, or plugin access may be gated behind it.\n2. **Create or initialize the project.** Scaffold it with the framework's official initializer, using a pinned runtime version (Node, Flutter SDK, etc.). This creates the manifest (`package.json`, `pubspec.yaml`, …) and lockfile that dependencies attach to. Installing packages before a project exists gives you stray global installs or no record of the dependency.\n3. **Make an initial commit.** Your working directory is a git repo with no commits yet. Committing the clean scaffold gives you a baseline to diff against or roll back to.\n4. **Install peer and base dependencies,** such as an animation runtime the shimmer library requires.\n5. **Install the shimmer package itself,** if you need one. Install it as a project dependency, not globally, so the lockfile records it.\n6. **Implement and verify.** Build one skeleton or sweep, check it on the target platform, and confirm it respects `prefers-reduced-motion` or the platform's equivalent.\n7. **Commit,** including the lockfile.\n\n## Recommendation\n\nIf this is a web or app loading skeleton, start with the dependency-free gradient-animation approach. That skips steps 1, 4, and 5 entirely. Only move to a package or an account-gated tool if the brief calls for something a gradient can't do, such as authored, multi-layer motion."
  },
  "draws": [
    {
      "id": "block",
      "mode": "with_skill",
      "draw_index": 0,
      "generation_hash": "e348cc93bd62fad61d3aba7879e612905cd0ee2e86fa0f87f59de7a2075aecea",
      "answer_sha256": "e348cc93bd62fad61d3aba7879e612905cd0ee2e86fa0f87f59de7a2075aecea",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Response uses data-composition-src pointing to the installed block path, matches data-composition-id to data-chart, sets data-start 2 and data-duration 15, and carries width/height plus a track index explicitly noting it is not z-order (CSS z-index controls layering).\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Response meets all four criteria: data-composition-src points to the installed block path, the id matches data-chart, start is 2 and duration 15, and dimensions plus track index are carried with track explicitly not treated as z-order.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Uses data-composition-src to the installed block path, matches data-chart id, sets start 2 and duration 15, and carries width, height, and track index while noting track is not z-order.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"The response uses data-composition-src for the installed block, matches data-composition-id to data-chart, sets data-start 2 and data-duration 15, carries width/height and track index, and notes track is not z-order.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Uses data-composition-src pointing to the installed block path, matches data-composition-id to data-chart, sets data-start=2 and data-duration=15, carries width/height, and explicitly says track index is timeline-only, not z-order.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "block",
      "mode": "with_skill",
      "draw_index": 1,
      "generation_hash": "6ba5fcbb8dc01658f36eee800ee87ac4bb08f1ecbcc885be2e20c60d221e575a",
      "answer_sha256": "6ba5fcbb8dc01658f36eee800ee87ac4bb08f1ecbcc885be2e20c60d221e575a",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Uses data-composition-src for the block, matches data-composition-id, sets start 2 and duration 15, and carries width, height, and track index while noting track does not control z-order.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Response uses data-composition-src pointing to the installed block path, matches data-composition-id to data-chart, sets data-start 2 and data-duration 15, and carries width/height plus data-track-index while explicitly noting track does not control z-order.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Response uses data-composition-src to a compositions path, matches data-composition-id to data-chart, sets data-start=2 and data-duration=15, carries width/height and track index, and explicitly says track index doesn't control z-order; the src path is assumed rather than confirmed installed, so criterion 1 is only partly met.\", \"criteria\": \"\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets all four criteria: data-composition-src points to the block, the id matches data-chart, start is 2 and duration is 15, and dimensions and track index are set with an explicit note that track does not control z-order.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Response uses data-composition-src pointing to the installed block path, matches data-composition-id to data-chart, sets data-start=2 and data-duration=15, carries width/height 1920x1080 and data-track-index, and explicitly notes track index does not control z-order.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "block",
      "mode": "with_skill",
      "draw_index": 2,
      "generation_hash": "11deb2f5f43f97f2504018250b8464a730e4d062ea916b49e2ff6a9d7ebfbe36",
      "answer_sha256": "11deb2f5f43f97f2504018250b8464a730e4d062ea916b49e2ff6a9d7ebfbe36",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Uses data-composition-src pointing to the installed block path, matches data-composition-id 'data-chart', sets data-start 2 and data-duration 15, and includes width/height with a track index while explicitly noting track is not z-order.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Uses data-composition-src pointing to the installed block path, matches data-composition-id to data-chart, sets data-start=2 and data-duration=15, and carries width/height with data-track-index while explicitly noting track index does not control visual z-order.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Uses data-composition-src pointing to the installed block path, matches data-chart ID, sets start 2 and duration 15, carries 1920x1080 dimensions and track index 1, and correctly notes track is not z-order.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"The response points data-composition-src at the installed block, matches data-chart, sets data-start 2 and data-duration 15, and includes 1920x1080 dimensions with a track index while noting it does not control z-order.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Uses data-composition-src pointing to the installed block path, matches data-composition-id to data-chart, sets start 2 and duration 15, carries width/height and a track index while explicitly noting track does not control visual z-order (CSS z-index does).\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "block",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 0,
      "generation_hash": "bc016bacb9e828ea86f1b24f8ac8fd6b97022249a0a545812d8620c9f1057162",
      "answer_sha256": "bc016bacb9e828ea86f1b24f8ac8fd6b97022249a0a545812d8620c9f1057162",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Matches data-composition-id, start 2, and duration 15 (rubric 2 and 3), but data-composition-src points to an invented path rather than an installed block (criterion 1 missed), and the data-track-index is described as a 'placeholder layer' without clearly disclaiming it as visual z-order (criterion 4 partly met).\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Matches data-composition-id and sets start 2 and duration 15, but data-composition-src uses a guessed path rather than an installed block, and the track index is described as a layer, not kept separate from z-order.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Matches data-composition-id 'data-chart', sets start 2 and duration 15, and carries 1920x1080 dimensions and a track index. It misses criterion 1 because the src path is invented rather than the installed block, and the track index is described as a 'layer', blurring it toward z-order.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Matches data-composition-id, sets start 2 and duration 15, and carries dimensions and track index without treating track as z-order. Misses full credit on the src criterion because the path is a guessed placeholder, not a known installed block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.25, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Meets only the id match (data-composition-id) and start/duration (2 and 15). The src path is an invented guess rather than the installed block, and track-index is described as a 'layer' needing non-overlap, which treats it as visual ordering.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "block",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 1,
      "generation_hash": "aaf3834309886a1e2485f663c4e8beb887ac281f25ab9fb130eb1fd175fafd80",
      "answer_sha256": "aaf3834309886a1e2485f663c4e8beb887ac281f25ab9fb130eb1fd175fafd80",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Response matches composition id data-chart, start 2, duration 15, and dimensions 1920x1080 (criteria 2, 3, and most of 4), but it uses a placeholder data-composition-src path rather than the installed block, failing criterion 1, and it never addresses track index or z-order.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Matches the composition id and sets start 2 and duration 15, and carries the dimensions. It misses the installed-block source (the src is a self-declared placeholder) and omits any track index.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Matches composition id, start 2 and duration 15, but uses a placeholder data-composition-src rather than the installed block and omits any track index.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Matches the composition id and sets start 2 and duration 15, but uses a placeholder data-composition-src rather than the installed block and omits any track index.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.25, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Matches data-composition-id 'data-chart', start 2, duration 15, and dimensions 1920x1080, but uses a placeholder src not grounded in the supplied facts (criterion 1 missed) and never addresses the track index (criterion 4 missed).\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "block",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 2,
      "generation_hash": "d97ba7cbfd7a25964b3859adfd421957e080e68cda5ebba6df3952bf386ed32b",
      "answer_sha256": "d97ba7cbfd7a25964b3859adfd421957e080e68cda5ebba6df3952bf386ed32b",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Matches the composition id, sets start 2 and duration 15, and carries the 1920x1080 dimensions and a track index framed as timeline conflict avoidance, not z-order. The src path is an admitted placeholder, not the installed block, so that criterion is missed.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Matches the composition id, start 2, duration 15, and dimensions, and treats track as timeline rather than z-order. It misses the installed-block src criterion by inventing a placeholder path, though it flags the assumption.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Matches the composition id, sets start 2 and duration 15, and carries 1920x1080 dimensions without treating track as z-order. It misses criterion 1 because the src path is an invented placeholder, not a known installed block location, though the response flags it as an assumption.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Matches the composition id, sets start 2 and duration 15, and carries dimensions and track index without treating track as z-order. It misses the first criterion because data-composition-src points to a guessed path rather than an installed block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Matches composition id, start 2 and duration 15, and carries dimensions with track index not treated as z-order. Misses the first point: data-composition-src uses an invented path rather than the installed block's location.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "block",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 3,
      "generation_hash": "af402ba82c73ab619ddbcb620e74507af76d90c5e067b110b7586238c276b140",
      "answer_sha256": "af402ba82c73ab619ddbcb620e74507af76d90c5e067b110b7586238c276b140",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Matches data-composition-id, sets start 2 and duration 15, and carries dimensions and track index without treating track as z-order. Misses the src criterion: the path is invented, though the response discloses this.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Matches the composition id and sets start 2 and duration 15, and carries dimensions. It uses an invented placeholder src path rather than the installed block, and describes track index as a 'layer slot', which implies z-order.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Met criteria 2 (matches data-composition-id) and 3 (start 2, duration 15); missed criterion 1 because the src is a placeholder path the response admits it invented, and criterion 4 is only partly met since width/height are carried but track-index is set without clarifying it isn't z-order.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Matches data-composition-id, sets start 2 and duration 15, and carries width, height, and a track index described as a timeline slot, not z-order. It misses the installed-block source criterion because it invented the data-composition-src path.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Matches id, start 2, duration 15, and dimensions (criteria 2, 3, 4 partly), but uses a placeholder data-composition-src rather than the installed block path (criterion 1 missed), and the track index is labeled as a layer slot without clarifying it isn't z-order (criterion 4 partial).\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "block",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 4,
      "generation_hash": "03b6abf7acf1b121bd1a90b4e0643cb8badec9e7034f91ce4bcc8e9627783418",
      "answer_sha256": "03b6abf7acf1b121bd1a90b4e0643cb8badec9e7034f91ce4bcc8e9627783418",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Meets the composition id match and start 2/duration 15 criteria, and carries dimensions. Misses the track index, and the data-composition-src path is invented rather than tied to an installed block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets composition id match, start 2 and duration 15, and uses data-composition-src, though the path is assumed. Misses the track index entirely, so the fourth criterion fails.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Matches the composition id and sets start 2 and duration 15, but omits any track index and uses an invented data-composition-src path instead of the installed block location.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets composition id match, start 2 and duration 15, and dimensions, and uses data-composition-src. It omits any track index, so the fourth criterion is missed.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Met: data-composition-src used (path assumed but flagged), id matches, start 2 and duration 15 set, dimensions carried. Missed: no track index is included at all.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "block",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 5,
      "generation_hash": "478912e6e162a0cceda1b6c78e114c7044d59f47814fdc8d3551f23211b93aa2",
      "answer_sha256": "478912e6e162a0cceda1b6c78e114c7044d59f47814fdc8d3551f23211b93aa2",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Matches the composition id and sets start 2 and duration 15, and carries dimensions; it misses the track index and uses a placeholder src rather than the installed block path.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Matches the composition id and sets start 2 and duration 15, but omits any track index and uses an invented placeholder src rather than the installed block path.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Meets the composition-id (matches 'data-chart') and start/duration (2 and 15) criteria, and carries dimensions. It misses the data-composition-src criterion, since the path is an admitted placeholder rather than the installed block, and it omits any track index.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Matches the composition id (0.25) and sets start 2 and duration 15 (0.25). Misses the src criterion because it invents a placeholder path, and omits any track index while carrying dimensions.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Matches the composition id and sets start 2 and duration 15, but uses an invented placeholder src rather than the installed block, and omits any track index while carrying dimensions.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "component",
      "mode": "with_skill",
      "draw_index": 0,
      "generation_hash": "734533e80b13bcf051f5fa42a398ce637502a4ef936cd635085a995bb9593d3b",
      "answer_sha256": "734533e80b13bcf051f5fa42a398ce637502a4ef936cd635085a995bb9593d3b",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"The response meets all four criteria: it says to paste markup into the host root, merge styles and script, avoid standalone dimensions for the component, and contrasts it clearly with the data-composition-src block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Covers copying markup into the host composition, merging styles and script into existing blocks, avoiding standalone dimensions for the component, and clearly distinguishing it from a data-composition-src block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Covers copying markup into the host composition (1), merging styles and script into the host (2), explicitly noting the snippet has no standalone dimensions or duration (3), and clearly distinguishing it from a data-composition-src block (4).\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Covers copying markup into the host composition, merging styles and script into existing blocks, not inventing standalone dimensions for the component (it inherits host canvas), and clearly distinguishes it from a data-composition-src block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Criterion 1 (copy markup into host), 2 (merge styles and script), 3 (no standalone dimensions for the component), and 4 (distinguished from data-composition-src block) are all satisfied.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "component",
      "mode": "with_skill",
      "draw_index": 1,
      "generation_hash": "393e42b6fc99e464a006f5d7792757554712c7430c58f0e34f00815bd636066e",
      "answer_sha256": "393e42b6fc99e464a006f5d7792757554712c7430c58f0e34f00815bd636066e",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets all four criteria: copies markup into the host, merges CSS and JS, states the component has no standalone dimensions, and distinguishes it from a data-composition-src block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Covers copying markup into the host root, merging CSS and JS before the timeline, stating the component has no standalone dimensions, and contrasting it with a data-composition-src block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Covers copying markup into the host composition (1), merging styles and script (2), avoids inventing standalone dimensions for the component (3), and clearly distinguishes it from a data-composition-src block (4).\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Met all four: copies markup into the host root div, merges CSS and JS, states the component has no standalone dimensions, and contrasts it with a data-composition-src block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets all four rubric points: copies markup into the host root, merges CSS and JS, states the component has no standalone dimensions, and distinguishes it from the data-composition-src block.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "component",
      "mode": "with_skill",
      "draw_index": 2,
      "generation_hash": "78049df21db43a7e83cc6c0c5c3c93c24ba6f65ad192571b98a37322635e8b5e",
      "answer_sha256": "78049df21db43a7e83cc6c0c5c3c93c24ba6f65ad192571b98a37322635e8b5e",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Covers all four rubric points: copies markup into the host, merges style and script, states the component has no standalone dimensions, and distinguishes it from a data-composition-src block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets all four criteria: copies markup into the host, merges styles and script, claims no standalone dimensions for the snippet, and clearly distinguishes it from the data-composition-src block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Covers all four rubric points: copies markup into the host root, merges style and script, gives the snippet no standalone dimensions, and distinguishes it from a data-composition-src block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets all four criteria: copies markup into the host, merges styles and script, states the component has no standalone dimensions, and distinguishes it from a data-composition-src block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Covers copying markup into the host, merging style and script, stating the component has no standalone dimensions, and clearly distinguishing it from a data-composition-src block.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "component",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 0,
      "generation_hash": "b77d6efb8a89a62f561d927089e4072206b7de7733813bf3b7e2e29854281448",
      "answer_sha256": "b77d6efb8a89a62f561d927089e4072206b7de7733813bf3b7e2e29854281448",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Covers all four rubric points: pastes markup into the host root, merges styles and script onto the host timeline, gives the snippet no standalone dimensions, and distinguishes it from a data-composition-src block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets all four criteria: markup goes inside the host root (1), styles and script are merged into the host (2), the snippet inherits the host canvas without invented dimensions (3), and it is contrasted with a data-composition-src block (4).\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets all four: markup is pasted into the host root, styles and timeline/script integration are merged, snippet dimensions are inherited rather than invented, and it is clearly distinguished from the data-composition-src block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Covers pasting markup into the host root, merging styles and timeline-registered scripts, inheriting host dimensions without inventing snippet sizes, and distinguishing it from a data-composition-src block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Met all four: pastes markup inside the host root, merges styles and script onto the host timeline, gives the snippet no standalone dimensions, and clearly distinguishes it from a data-composition-src block.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "component",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 1,
      "generation_hash": "5d00e4f4757c314e957f5e2c78d36b025549e8eed928675724c702a82c9976c3",
      "answer_sha256": "5d00e4f4757c314e957f5e2c78d36b025549e8eed928675724c702a82c9976c3",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets criteria 1 (paste markup into host composition), 2 (merge styles and animation into host scope), and 4 (distinguishes component snippet from standalone block via a comparison table referencing sub-composition/clip embedding); misses criterion 3 since it never explicitly states it avoids inventing standalone dimensions, though it does say the component inherits the host's full frame.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets copying markup into the host, merging styles and animation, and not inventing dimensions; misses the explicit data-composition-src block distinction, describing blocks only generically.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets copying markup into the host, merging styles and animation, and avoiding invented dimensions; distinguishes component from block by reference/sub-composition but never names data-composition-src.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets criteria 1 (paste markup into host), 2 (merge CSS and timeline-attached animation), and 3 (no invented snippet dimensions); misses 4 because it never names the data-composition-src mechanism for block references.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets criteria 1 (paste markup into host), 2 (merge styles and timeline animation), and 3 (no invented snippet dimensions); misses 4 because it never names or distinguishes a data-composition-src block, describing blocks only generically.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "component",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 2,
      "generation_hash": "fd8d5dd9a36bca106b300346caa1b10697b388dd855f56ff799a13e4df49b93b",
      "answer_sha256": "fd8d5dd9a36bca106b300346caa1b10697b388dd855f56ff799a13e4df49b93b",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Covers pasting markup into the host root, merging CSS and script, avoiding invented snippet dimensions, and distinguishing snippets from referenced blocks, though it never names data-composition-src.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Covers pasting markup into the host root, merging CSS and script into the host, and not giving the snippet its own dimensions. It distinguishes the snippet from a referenced nested-composition block, though it never names data-composition-src.\"}",
        "```json\n{\n  \"score\": 0.75,\n  \"pass\": true,\n  \"reason\": \"Meets criteria 1 (paste markup into the host root), 2 (merge CSS and script into the existing setup), and 3 (no standalone dimensions invented); criterion 4 is only partly met because it distinguishes a referenced block but never names data-composition-src.\"\n}\n```",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets all four rubric points: it says to paste the markup into the host root, merge CSS and script into the existing setup, gives no standalone snippet dimensions, and contrasts snippets with referenced nested-composition blocks, though it never names data-composition-src.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Covers pasting markup into the host root, merging CSS and script, giving no standalone dimensions for the snippet, and distinguishing it from a referenced nested-composition block, though it never names data-composition-src.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "component",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 3,
      "generation_hash": "eb3ed122d26155e94c240980207142ed172872732e35660a17aa11f993b40a61",
      "answer_sha256": "eb3ed122d26155e94c240980207142ed172872732e35660a17aa11f993b40a61",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Covers copying markup into the host root, merging styles and timeline/script integration, avoiding invented snippet dimensions, and distinguishing it from the data-composition-src block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Covers copying markup into the host root, merging styles and timeline-driven animation, avoiding invented snippet dimensions via full-frame inset:0, and clearly distinguishing it from a data-composition-src block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Covers copying markup into the host root, merging styles and timeline-driven script integration, avoiding invented standalone dimensions, and clearly distinguishing the snippet from a data-composition-src block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Covers copying markup into the host (step 1), merging styles and timeline/script integration (steps 2-3), avoids inventing standalone dimensions, and clearly distinguishes the snippet from the data-composition-src block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Covers copying markup into the host root (1), merging styles and timeline script integration (2), giving no invented standalone dimensions for the snippet (3), and clearly contrasting it with a data-composition-src block (4).\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "component",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 4,
      "generation_hash": "d50b94f84dfef5ef8966ed12bfa7cb347ab03a78f674844d58472abbc7b3d216",
      "answer_sha256": "d50b94f84dfef5ef8966ed12bfa7cb347ab03a78f674844d58472abbc7b3d216",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets copying markup into the host, merging styles and script, and not inventing standalone dimensions; distinguishes the standalone block as a referenced sub-composition but never names data-composition-src.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets criteria 1 (insert markup into host composition), 2 (merge CSS and JS), and 3 (uses inset:0, invents no standalone dimensions). Criterion 4 is only conceptually met: it contrasts with a referenced sub-composition but never names data-composition-src.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Met criterion 1 (place snippet markup in host composition) and criterion 2 (merge styles and script); missed 3 since it doesn't invent dimensions but the response never explicitly avoids inventing standalone dimensions, and missed 4 by only contrasting with standalone blocks rather than explicitly distinguishing from a data-composition-src reference.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Met criteria 1 (place markup as last child of host), 2 (merge CSS and drive JS from host timeline), and 3 (no invented standalone dimensions). Missed 4: it contrasts with a 'standalone block' but never names data-composition-src.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets copying markup into the host, merging styles and script, and not inventing snippet dimensions; it distinguishes from a sub-composition block but never names data-composition-src.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "component",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 5,
      "generation_hash": "c37acab2df3b457d797b70bd19070a7d1c45704695b476a90d9971f0dba91b49",
      "answer_sha256": "c37acab2df3b457d797b70bd19070a7d1c45704695b476a90d9971f0dba91b49",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets criteria 1 (place markup as last child of host root), 2 (merge styles and register script with host timeline), and 3 (no invented standalone dimensions). Misses 4: it contrasts with a generic standalone block but never names or distinguishes a data-composition-src block.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets copy-markup into host, style/script merge, and no invented snippet dimensions; misses point 4 because it contrasts with a generic 'referenced' standalone block and never names data-composition-src.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets criteria 1 (place markup as last child of host root), 2 (merge CSS and route script to host timeline), and 3 (no invented standalone dimensions). Criterion 4 is only partly met: it contrasts standalone blocks generically but never names data-composition-src.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets criteria 1-3: it covers placing markup in the host root, merging styles and script onto the host timeline, and inheriting host canvas size without inventing dimensions. Misses criterion 4 because it never names data-composition-src, describing the standalone block only generically.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets copying markup into the host, style and script merging, and not inventing snippet dimensions; misses the explicit data-composition-src distinction, describing a generic standalone block instead.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "search",
      "mode": "with_skill",
      "draw_index": 0,
      "generation_hash": "d707fe941e07b87de24f1ee7bbb60cd7121c1ef473b9b8c548b82432640b8631",
      "answer_sha256": "d707fe941e07b87de24f1ee7bbb60cd7121c1ef473b9b8c548b82432640b8631",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Searches the catalog by desired effect first, states discovery needs no account or install, confirms fit before running add, and reports gaps before hand-authoring the shimmer effect; all four rubric points are met.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets criteria 1 (searches by desired effect first), 2 (states search needs no project, account, or installs), and 4 (avoids hand-building, points to catalog first); criterion 3 is met only partially since it installs after fit-checking but describes wiring rather than explicitly verifying fit.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets all four criteria: it searches the catalog by effect first, states that search needs no project, account, or installs, confirms fit before installing, and reports a gap before hand-authoring.\"}",
        "{\n  \"score\": 1.0,\n  \"pass\": true,\n  \"reason\": \"Response searches by desired effect first, states discovery needs no project, account, or installs, installs only after checking fit, and reports gaps before hand-authoring the effect.\"\n}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Searches by desired effect first, states discovery needs no project, account, or installs, installs only after confirming fit, and reports gaps before hand-authoring the effect, meeting all four criteria.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "search",
      "mode": "with_skill",
      "draw_index": 1,
      "generation_hash": "bf05587dc262f1024b15a2650049e1d9d43c1e65c3d96cb81c63579165eff8e4",
      "answer_sha256": "bf05587dc262f1024b15a2650049e1d9d43c1e65c3d96cb81c63579165eff8e4",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets criteria 1 (search by desired effect first), 2 (explicitly states search needs no project, account, or installs), and 4 (checks catalog before hand-building); criterion 3 is met only partly since install follows setup and fit-check is implied rather than explicit.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"The response searches the catalog by described effect first, states search needs no project, account, or installs, confirms fit before installing, and says to check the registry before hand-authoring.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets all four criteria: searches the catalog by described effect first, states search needs no project, account, or install, installs after checking results, and says to check the registry before hand-building.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Searches by described effect first, states search needs no project, account, or install, checks results before installing, and says to report a gap before hand-authoring the effect.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"The response searches the catalog by desired effect first, states search needs no project, account, or install, checks fit in results before installing, and says to search before hand-authoring the effect.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "search",
      "mode": "with_skill",
      "draw_index": 2,
      "generation_hash": "2d534944f17f39ec21b08935f10679bd95d128da483902114215057785ff69ad",
      "answer_sha256": "2d534944f17f39ec21b08935f10679bd95d128da483902114215057785ff69ad",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets criteria 1 (searches catalog by desired effect first), 2 (states no project or account needed for search), and 4 (checks registry before hand-building CSS/GSAP); criterion 3 (install after checking fit) is satisfied only partially, since it installs after search without an explicit fit check step, so this scores 0.75.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Search by desired effect comes first, the response states no project, account, or install is needed for search, installation follows discovery with a fit check (item type and pick-or-report-gap), and it says to search before hand-authoring CSS or GSAP.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 1.0, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Response searches the catalog by described effect before building, states no project, account, or install is needed for search, installs after discovery and type/fit check, and avoids hand-building the effect first.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets criteria 1 (search by desired effect first), 2 (states search needs no project or account), and 4 (checks registry before hand-building); criterion 3 is only implied since install is described but the fit check after selecting is not explicit.\"}",
        "{\n  \"score\": 1.0,\n  \"pass\": true,\n  \"reason\": \"Meets all four criteria: searches the catalog by desired effect first, states search needs no project or account, installs the selected item after picking it, and says to search before hand-authoring the effect.\"\n}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "search",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 0,
      "generation_hash": "22bd0c2f5bba8362dd4396b29179cb9280964936aca4ec7ac1165517fa493599",
      "answer_sha256": "22bd0c2f5bba8362dd4396b29179cb9280964936aca4ec7ac1165517fa493599",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Met criterion 2 (search needs no account) and criterion 3 (install after fit check). Missed criterion 1, since it never searches a catalog by effect first, and criterion 4, since it proposes hand-building the CSS shimmer before looking at existing options.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.0, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"The response never mentions searching a catalog by desired effect first; it instead starts with clarifying questions and hand-building a CSS gradient as the default, missing criteria 1, 3, and 4, though it does avoid assuming an account is needed (criterion 2).\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Criterion 2 (no install/account assumed for discovery) and criterion 3 (install after checking fit) are met. Criteria 1 and 4 are missed: it leads with hand-built CSS keyframes before searching a catalog by effect.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.0, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Rubric requires searching a catalog by desired effect first and installing a selected item after checking fit; the response never mentions searching a catalog or registry for a shimmer item and instead proposes hand-building CSS, missing criteria 1, 3, and 4 (criterion 2 partially met).\", \"score_note\": \"\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Meets criterion 2 (discovery needs no account) and criterion 3 (install only after fit is checked), but misses 1 and 4: it leads with hand-building a CSS shimmer rather than searching a catalog by effect first.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "search",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 1,
      "generation_hash": "5c8163265a92fb2c4dfea60e29d33bc48890882eee4e440b0496ab70a00c04d4",
      "answer_sha256": "5c8163265a92fb2c4dfea60e29d33bc48890882eee4e440b0496ab70a00c04d4",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Meets the no-assumed-account (criterion 2) and install-after-fit (criterion 3) points, but never says to search the catalog by desired effect first and recommends hand-built plain CSS before looking, missing criteria 1 and 4.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.25, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Response offers a sensible discovery table and install ordering, but never states a search-the-catalog-by-effect step first (criterion 1), instead starting with brief-pinning and hand-built CSS recommendation (criterion 4 missed), so only criterion 2 (no account needed for search) and arguably 3 are partially met; scored 0.25 for the account-ordering point alone.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.0, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"The response never searches a catalog by desired effect first; it jumps to hand-built CSS as the recommendation (missing criteria 1 and 4), and it frames installation as likely needed then recommends skipping it, with install-after-fit-check only loosely addressed (criteria 2-3 partially unmet).\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.25, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Misses criterion 1 (no search-by-effect step) and criterion 4 (recommends hand-built CSS first without checking the catalog); partially meets criterion 2 and fully meets criterion 3 (checks fit before installing).\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Meets the no-account-for-discovery and check-fit-before-install criteria, but never searches a catalog by effect first and recommends hand-building CSS before looking at options.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "search",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 2,
      "generation_hash": "1d3ea5ac747c81f95e5fb7f2f4b1068d5387c109a95daa7175a0752e7210af7f",
      "answer_sha256": "1d3ea5ac747c81f95e5fb7f2f4b1068d5387c109a95daa7175a0752e7210af7f",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Met: no account needed for discovery (2) and install follows fit-checking (3). Missed: no explicit catalog search by effect first (1), and it recommends hand-building a CSS gradient before looking at options (4).\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.25, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Criterion 2 (no account needed for search) is met via 'Browse anonymously' and step 3, and criterion 3 (install after checking fit) is met; criterion 1 (search catalog by effect first) and criterion 4 (avoid hand-building before looking) are missed, since it recommends a hand-built CSS gradient as the default.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Meets criteria 1-3: searches by effect, assumes no account for browsing, and installs after checking fit. Misses criterion 4 by recommending a hand-built CSS gradient as the default before looking at the catalog.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Meets criteria 2 (search needs no account) and 3 (install after checking fit), but misses 1 (no search by desired effect first) and 4 (recommends hand-building a CSS gradient before looking at the catalog).\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Meets the no-account-for-search and install-after-fit-check criteria, but misses search-by-effect-first and recommends hand-building a CSS shimmer before looking at the catalog.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "search",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 3,
      "generation_hash": "6f36cb2219af862267b5f39975b09f9f7b0591390fa6aae87b3597c56f4a98d2",
      "answer_sha256": "6f36cb2219af862267b5f39975b09f9f7b0591390fa6aae87b3597c56f4a98d2",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 0.75, \"pass\": true, \"reason\": \"Meets discovery-before-install, no-account-needed-for-search, and install-after-fit criteria, but misses the avoid-hand-building criterion by leading with and recommending a hand-rolled CSS shimmer first.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Criteria 2 (search needs no install or account) and 3 (install after checking fit) are met. Criterion 1 is weak because it doesn't search a catalog by effect first, and criterion 4 is missed because it leads with and recommends hand-building the CSS shimmer before looking at existing items.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Meets the no-account-for-search (2) and install-after-fit (3) criteria, but misses avoiding hand-building first (4) by recommending pure-CSS prototyping before checking packages, and only loosely meets catalog-search-first (1).\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Meets criteria 2 (no account needed for search) and 3 (install after fit check). Misses 4: it recommends hand-rolled CSS first, before looking at packages. Criterion 1 (catalog search by effect) is not explicitly addressed.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Meets no-account-for-search (point 2) and install-after-fit (point 3). Misses point 4 by recommending a hand-built CSS shimmer first, and point 1 is only loosely met since it never frames discovery as a catalog search by effect.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "search",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 4,
      "generation_hash": "61e224bf5ad83f374d7aba5756e6eb28766f3f0f50614d6b0347a3973aadbdbe",
      "answer_sha256": "61e224bf5ad83f374d7aba5756e6eb28766f3f0f50614d6b0347a3973aadbdbe",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Met criteria 2 (search needs no account) and 3 (install after checking fit). Missed criteria 1 and 4: it lists hand-built pure CSS first and recommends it by default rather than searching the catalog by effect first.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Response does not search a catalog by desired effect first; it surveys options generically and recommends hand-built pure CSS before any catalog lookup, missing criteria 1 and 4, but it correctly treats search as needing no account and installs after fit-checking (criteria 2 and 3).\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Meets criterion 2 (discovery doesn't assume an account) and criterion 3 (install follows fit check), but misses criterion 1 (no catalog search by effect) and criterion 4 (recommends hand-building a CSS shimmer before looking).\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.25, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"The response covers discovery-before-install ordering and avoids assuming an account for search, but it never says to search a catalog by desired effect first, and it hand-builds the CSS shimmer as its top recommendation instead of looking up an existing one. Only criteria 2 and partly 3 are met.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Meets criteria 2 (search needs no account, stated as 'Discovery needs neither') and 3 (install follows fit-checking), but misses 1 (never searches a catalog by desired effect first) and 4 (recommends hand-building pure CSS before looking at registries).\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "search",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 5,
      "generation_hash": "8d69a0fb00a72e3359fa5f9185b30b4cd55d49df7736410edef126015585c25c",
      "answer_sha256": "8d69a0fb00a72e3359fa5f9185b30b4cd55d49df7736410edef126015585c25c",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\n  \"score\": 0.5,\n  \"pass\": false,\n  \"reason\": \"Meets criteria 2 (no account or install needed to search) and 3 (install after fit check), but misses 1 (no explicit catalog search by effect) and 4 (recommends hand-building CSS shimmer before looking at registries).\"\n}",
        "{\"score\": 0.25, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Criterion 2 is met (no account/install assumed for discovery), and the response partly covers criterion 1 by listing candidate options, but it never searches the catalog by desired effect first, and it hand-builds the shimmer in CSS without looking at registry options (criterion 4 missed), and criterion 3 (install selected item after fit check) is not really addressed.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Meets the no-account-for-search (2) and install-after-fit (3) criteria. It does not clearly search a catalog by effect (1), and it hand-writes the shimmer CSS as its decision outcome (4 missed).\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Meets the no-account-for-search and check-fit-before-install criteria, but never searches a catalog by desired effect and recommends hand-building the CSS shimmer in the decision step rather than selecting an existing item.\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Meets the no-account/no-install-for-search point and install-after-fit-check point, but does not clearly search the catalog by desired effect and offers hand-built CSS as the decided option before looking at registries.\"}"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "search",
      "mode": "baseline",
      "draw_index": 6,
      "generation_hash": "3a8ee165adb394f6001e8ca82c78ad33865acc5a7de789c6eea7b9bdfb6e90df",
      "answer_sha256": "3a8ee165adb394f6001e8ca82c78ad33865acc5a7de789c6eea7b9bdfb6e90df",
      "status": "measured",
      "judge_outputs": [
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"It checks fit and installs only after choosing (criterion 3) and avoids assuming an account is needed (criterion 2), but never searches a catalog by effect and recommends hand-building a CSS gradient first (missing criteria 1 and 4).\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Meets criteria 2 (no assumed account or install for discovery) and 3 (checks fit before installing), but misses 1 (never searches a catalog by effect) and 4 (recommends hand-building a CSS gradient without looking first).\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.5, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"Met criteria 2 (no assumed account or install for discovery) and 3 (checks fit before installing). Missed criteria 1 (no catalog search by effect first) and 4 (recommends hand-building a CSS gradient before looking).\"}",
        "{\"score\": 0.0, \"pass\": false, \"reason\": \"The response never searches a catalog by desired effect first; it instead says to clarify the target and recommends hand-building a CSS gradient animation before looking at existing options, missing criteria 1, 3, and 4 and failing criterion 2 by making account creation a conditional step.\", \"score_breakdown\": {\"criterion_1_search_catalog_first\": 0, \"criterion_2_no_assumed_install_or_account\": 0.25, \"criterion_3_install_after_checking_fit\": 0, \"criterion_4_avoid_hand_building_before_looking\": 0}}",
        "{\n  \"score\": 0.5,\n  \"pass\": false,\n  \"reason\": \"Misses criterion 1 (no search of the catalog by desired effect) and criterion 4 (it recommends hand-building a CSS gradient before looking at existing options); partially meets criteria 2 and 3 by checking fit before installing and not assuming an account is needed.\"\n}"
      ]
    }
  ]
}